Independent guide. Electricity: EIA August 2026 US average. Gas: EIA March 2026. Efficiency thresholds: DOE and ENERGY STAR, checked 10 November 2026.
Heat pump vs gas furnace operating cost 2026: COP, AFUE and when each wins
At national average prices (electricity 18.16 cents per kWh (EIA, August 2026), residential gas $1.56 per therm (EIA, March 2026)), 100,000 Btu of heat costs $1.64 from a 95 percent AFUE gas furnace and $1.91 from a heat pump at HSPF2 9.5. The heat pump wins whenever its COP is above about 3.2: in mild weather, with top-tier equipment, where electricity is cheap relative to gas, and always against resistance, propane or oil heat. The table shows the crossover at each COP.
Cost per 100,000 Btu at each COP vs a gas furnace
| Heat pump COP | Heat pump | Cheaper vs 95% furnace ($1.64) | Cheaper vs 80% furnace ($1.95) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 (backup) | $5.32 | Gas by 69% | Gas by 63% |
| 1.75 (cold-climate min. at 5F) | $3.04 | Gas by 46% | Gas by 36% |
| 2.0 | $2.66 | Gas by 38% | Gas by 27% |
| 2.5 | $2.13 | Gas by 23% | Gas by 8% |
| 3.0 | $1.77 | Gas by 7% | HP by 9% |
| 3.5 | $1.52 | HP by 7% | HP by 22% |
| 4.0 | $1.33 | HP by 19% | HP by 32% |
Our arithmetic at national average prices: heat pump = 29.3 kWh per 100,000 Btu / COP x 18.16 cents (EIA US residential, August 2026); furnace = $1.56 per therm / AFUE (EIA US residential gas, March 2026, $16.16 per thousand cubic feet at 10.36 therms per Mcf). "About even" means within 5 percent. Your own crossover moves with your local price ratio: the state table runs it with state prices.
Why heat pumps deliver more heat than electricity consumed
A heat pump does not make heat from electricity; it moves heat from outside the home to inside, using electricity to drive the refrigerant cycle. The refrigerant absorbs heat from outdoor air (or the ground), is compressed, and releases that heat indoors. COP is the heat moved divided by the electricity used, and it can be well above 1 because most of the delivered heat was already outside.
As the outdoor temperature drops there is less heat to extract and a wider gap to lift it across, so COP and output both fall. The balance point is the outdoor temperature at which the heat pump's output no longer covers the home's heat loss; below it, backup heat makes up the difference. For a cold climate, choose a unit whose balance point sits below your local design temperature, which in practice means a model on NEEP's cold-climate list or with ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation.
AFUE vs delivered efficiency
AFUE measures how much of the fuel's energy leaves the furnace as heat over a season, accounting for cycling and standby losses. Condensing furnaces reach 90 percent and above; ENERGY STAR requires 95 percent AFUE for gas furnaces sold for the US South and 97 percent for the rest of the US and Canada. The federal minimum for non-weatherized gas furnaces is 80 percent.
AFUE is measured at the furnace, not at the registers. ENERGY STAR puts typical duct leakage at 20 to 30 percent of the air moving through the system. The same ducts carry a heat pump's air, so leakage raises both systems' bills by the same proportion and does not change which one is cheaper per unit of heat. Sealing ducts cuts the bill for either.
Worked example: a home that needs 60 million Btu a season
Suppose your gas bills show the home used about 632 therms last winter in a 95 percent furnace, which is 60 million Btu of delivered heat (therms x 0.95 / 10). At national average prices the furnace costs about $985 a season. A heat pump averaging the seasonal COP of an HSPF2 9.5 unit (2.8) costs about $1,147; one averaging COP 3.5 costs about $912.
Redo it with your own numbers: your therms, your gas price per therm (on the bill, including delivery), your electricity price per kWh, and the HSPF2 of the unit you are quoted. In a state where electricity is expensive and gas cheap the furnace wins by more; where electricity is cheap the heat pump wins. Install cost then comes from quotes and local rebates, priced against a furnace plus a new AC when both are due.
When gas still wins on a total-cost basis
Gas tends to keep the edge in four situations. First, cold regions with cheap gas and expensive electricity, where the heat pump spends many hours below the break-even COP and rebates do not close the gap. Second, homes with a fairly new high-efficiency furnace, where retiring working equipment early is its own cost. Third, homes whose electrical service would need an upgrade to carry the heat pump and its backup strips. Fourth, homes not replacing the AC, where a furnace-only swap is the cheaper like-for-like job.
Outside those cases the decision is closer than the national averages suggest, and it turns on three local numbers: your price ratio, your heat need and the install quotes after rebates. A dual-fuel system is the hedge when the answer is close, because it runs whichever fuel is cheaper at each outdoor temperature.
Sources and further reading
- NEEP Cold Climate ASHP product list
- ENERGY STAR heat pumps
- EIA natural gas residential prices
- DOE furnace guide
- Electric vs gas heating by state
- Electric heat pump running cost
- Electric water heater (HPWH context)
- How we source these numbers