Independent guide. Comparison uses 2026 EIA state-average residential rates and EIA state-average natural gas prices.Gas prices checked against EIA 10 November 2026
Electric vs gas heating cost 2026: the local price ratio decides
At early-2026 EIA prices, a 95 percent AFUE gas furnace is cheaper to run than a standard heat pump (HSPF2 9.5, seasonal COP about 2.8) in most gas-served states, especially where gas is cheap (Illinois, Ohio, Idaho, Nevada). The heat pump wins where electricity is cheap relative to gas (Washington) and roughly ties in Texas, Georgia and Oregon. Against resistance electric, propane or oil heat, the heat pump wins everywhere by a wide margin, and top-tier HSPF2 12+ equipment shifts several more states its way.
Per million BTU cost by state
| State | Elec rate | Gas $/therm | HP $/MMBtu | Furnace $/MMBtu | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | 29.8c | $2.21 | $31 | $23 | Gas |
| New York | 28.6c | $1.54 | $30 | $16 | Gas |
| Massachusetts | 30.5c | $2.49 | $32 | $26 | Gas |
| Texas | 15.9c | $1.59 | $17 | $17 | Even |
| Illinois | 19.3c | $0.93 | $20 | $10 | Gas |
| Ohio | 19.4c | $1.06 | $20 | $11 | Gas |
| Washington | 14.6c | $1.68 | $15 | $18 | Heat pump |
| Idaho | 13.4c | $0.65 | $14 | $7 | Gas |
| Georgia | 15.9c | $1.51 | $17 | $16 | Even |
| North Carolina | 14.9c | $1.73 | $16 | $18 | Heat pump |
| Tennessee | 13.4c | $1.08 | $14 | $11 | Gas |
| Arizona | 15.1c | $1.66 | $16 | $17 | Heat pump (slim) |
| Nevada | 12.7c | $0.90 | $13 | $9 | Gas |
| Oregon | 15.9c | $1.48 | $17 | $16 | Even |
Heat pump assumes HSPF2 9.5 (typical seasonal average COP about 2.8). Gas furnace assumes 95 percent AFUE. Electricity rates are EIA August 2026 state residential averages; gas prices are EIA January 2026 state residential averages (peak heating month). "Even" means under 8 percent difference and "slim" 8 to 15 percent, computed from the unrounded costs; either system is reasonable. Florida is omitted because EIA reports no January 2026 residential gas price for it.
The BTU equivalence math
Heating fuels are not directly comparable because they are sold in different units. Natural gas is sold by the therm (100,000 BTU of fuel content). Electricity is sold by the kWh (3,412 BTU). Propane is sold by the gallon (91,452 BTU, per EIA). Oil is sold by the gallon (138,500 BTU). To compare apples to apples, you need to know two things: the fuel cost per unit (per therm, per kWh, per gallon) and the efficiency at which the equipment converts the fuel to delivered heat.
A 95 percent AFUE gas furnace turns 95 percent of the fuel's energy into heat. EIA put the US residential gas price at $16.16 per thousand cubic feet in March 2026; at 1,036 Btu per cubic foot that is $1.56 per therm, and $16.42 per million Btu delivered. A heat pump at HSPF2 9.5 (seasonal COP about 2.8) turns 1 kWh into about 9,500 Btu of heat; at the August 2026 US average of 18.16 cents per kWh, 1 million Btu costs $19.12 delivered, so gas is cheaper by about $2.70 per million Btu at national averages. The ratio swings by state, which is why the table above runs the same arithmetic on 14 states' own prices.
Where the heat pump is competitive: South and parts of the West
Southern states (Georgia, Texas, North Carolina) have electricity rates below the US average, gas prices that are not particularly cheap (often above $1.50 per therm), and short heating seasons, so the running-cost comparison lands roughly even. The decisive Southern argument is capital, not fuel: the same heat pump unit serves the long cooling season, so its cost is essentially the cost of the AC plus a small premium for the heating function, while the cooling-season utility of a separate gas furnace is zero.
In the Pacific Northwest the picture splits. Washington (14.6 cents per kWh in August 2026 against $1.68 per therm gas in January 2026) is one of the few states where the heat pump beats gas on running cost, and the regional efficiency programs (Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance, Energy Trust of Oregon, BPA) heavily subsidise the conversion. Oregon lands roughly even. Idaho is the counterexample: its electricity is cheap, but its residential gas (about $0.65 per therm in January 2026, among the cheapest in the country) is far cheaper still, so gas wins decisively on running cost there.
Why gas still wins in parts of the Northeast and Upper Midwest
Northeast states pair expensive electricity with mid-to-high gas prices: Massachusetts at 30.5 cents per kWh (August 2026) against $2.49 per therm gas (January 2026), New York at 28.6 cents against $1.54. The table above shows the result at a standard heat pump's efficiency. The Northeast also has long, cold heating seasons where heat pump efficiency drops below the rated value for hundreds of hours per year, eroding the heat pump's per-BTU advantage further.
Several state programs (Mass Save, NYSERDA Clean Heat, Maine Efficiency Maine) are explicitly trying to flip this math through aggressive rebates that reduce the heat pump's effective cost or that target the cold-climate variants which maintain efficiency at low temperatures. With the federal 25C credit now expired (2026 installs no longer qualify), these state programs plus the federally funded Home Energy Rebates for income-qualified households, where a state has launched them, are what still tilt the install economics toward the heat pump even when the per-BTU operating cost is roughly even with gas. The Northeast transition is happening but more slowly than in the South and West because the operating-cost case is closer to neutral.
Cold-climate heat pumps change the math in 2026
Cold-climate heat pumps keep useful output at outdoor temperatures where standard heat pumps hand over to expensive resistance backup. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation requires a COP of at least 1.75 and at least 70 percent of rated 47F capacity at 5F, so a qualifying unit avoids most of the resistance penalty in a cold snap. A higher seasonal efficiency also lowers the whole-season cost: the crossover table shows the COP a heat pump needs to beat gas at national prices.
Northeast Energy Efficiency Partnerships (NEEP) maintains a public Cold Climate ASHP product list at ashp.neep.org with performance data at standard test conditions (47F, 17F, 5F outdoor). In climate zone 5 or colder, choose a product from that list or one carrying ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation.
Dual-fuel as the bridge strategy
For households with an existing gas furnace that is not yet at end of life, a dual-fuel hybrid system (heat pump for shoulder seasons and mild winter days, gas furnace for the coldest hours) runs whichever is cheaper at each outdoor temperature. Set the switch-over at the temperature where the heat pump's COP falls below the break-even for your prices; below that the thermostat switches to gas. The capital cost is the heat pump (new equipment) plus retention of the existing gas furnace.
Dual-fuel suits Mid-Atlantic and Midwest homes with a furnace that still has years left: the heat pump carries most of the season and the furnace covers cold snaps, without the cost of retiring working equipment. Ask your utility whether it offers a dual-fuel or heat pump rebate before you choose.
Sources and further reading
- EIA natural gas residential prices
- EIA state electricity rates
- NEEP Cold Climate ASHP list
- ENERGY STAR heat pumps
- Electric heat pump running cost
- Heat pump vs gas furnace deep dive
- Electric water heater running cost
- How we source these numbers