Independent guide. Comparison uses the EIA US residential propane price ($2.67/gal, 30 March 2026, final 2025-26 heating-season reading) and the EIA US average electricity rate (18.16c/kWh, August 2026).Model checked 10 November 2026
Electric vs propane water heater cost 2026: HPWH wins in most US households
Heating 50 gallons of water a day costs about $13 a month with a heat pump water heater, $26 with a condensing propane tankless, $38 with a propane tank and $49 with a resistance electric tank, at the EIA US averages (18.16 cents per kWh, $2.67 per gallon of propane). Propane beats resistance electric; the heat pump water heater beats both. The table covers other usage levels, and the method is below so you can redo it with your own prices.
Monthly cost comparison: same hot water, different fuels
| Water heater | UEF | 30 gal/day | 50 gal/day | 70 gal/day |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Propane tank | 0.65 | $23 | $38 | $54 |
| Propane tankless, condensing | 0.95 | $16 | $26 | $37 |
| Electric resistance tank | 0.92 | $29 | $49 | $69 |
| Electric tankless | 0.99 | $27 | $46 | $64 |
| Heat pump water heater | 3.5 | $8 | $13 | $18 |
Our arithmetic, not a survey: gallons per day x 8.34 lb x a 67F rise (58F inlet to 125F), x 30.4 days, divided by the UEF and by 3,412 Btu per kWh or 91,452 Btu per gallon of propane. Prices: 18.16 cents per kWh (EIA, August 2026) and $2.67 per gallon (EIA, 30 March 2026). The UEFs are example inputs: use the figure on the EnergyGuide label of the unit you are quoted. See propanecostpergallon.com for current state propane prices.
The arithmetic, step by step
Fuels are sold in different units, so compare them per million Btu of hot water delivered. Propane: 91,452 Btu per gallon (EIA). A unit rated UEF 0.95 delivers 86,879 Btu per gallon, so at $2.67 a gallon a million Btu costs $30.78; a UEF 0.65 tank, $44.98.
Electricity: 3,412 Btu per kWh. A resistance tank at UEF 0.92 needs about 319 kWh per million Btu, $57.85 at 18.16 cents. A heat pump water heater at UEF 3.5 needs about 84 kWh, $15.21. The heat pump moves heat from the surrounding air into the tank, which is why it beats every combustion water heater on running cost at national prices.
When propane still makes sense
On running cost alone, propane would need to fall to about $1.32 a gallon for a UEF 0.95 propane unit to match a UEF 3.5 heat pump water heater at the US average electricity rate; at your own rates, scale that figure in proportion to your cents per kWh. The practical cases for propane are different: a mechanical room too cold or too small for a heat pump water heater (check the manufacturer's stated air volume and temperature range), a home whose electrical service cannot take another large load, or a working propane unit that is not yet due for replacement.
Purchase price
Install prices come from local quotes, and we do not publish a national range we cannot source. Get quotes for both types, subtract any rebate, and divide the difference by the monthly running-cost saving from the table at your own usage: that is the payback in months. The federal 25C credit expired for property placed in service after 31 December 2025, so a 2026 install relies on state and utility rebates.
Sources and further reading
- EIA propane residential prices
- ENERGY STAR water heaters
- IRS Form 5695 (25C credit)
- Electric water heater running cost (full HPWH guide)
- Electric vs gas heating cost
- Electric heat pump running cost
- For current propane prices by state: see the sister site propanecostpergallon.com
- How we source these numbers